The Shark that Was Circling the Water

My soon-to-be-ex-wife (F34) and I have had a couple of swinger encounters in the past. Three to be exact. Two were MFM and one was FFM. I have posted about those in the past. What those encounters had in common was that they were completely spontaneous, taking advantage of the moment and the situation amongst consenting adults.

My wife and I have been separated for nearly all of 2025 and are in the process of divorcing, because she found evidence of me cheating some years ago. Since we are still legally married, I will refer to her as my wife.

A little over a year ago, we had a group of friends over to our place for drinks. One of them, one of my wife’s best friends, and coincidentally the girl that we had the FFM threesome with, brought a date. She is a nice girl who has been single for a while. She had mentioned that she was going on dates with this guy, but that she did not see much of a future but was still trying to give him a chance because the guy was making an effort to charm her and seemed like a good catch. Let us call the girl Chris and her date Eddie.

We all made fast friends with him and whenever he left the room, we would tell her to give him a chance. Her responses were lukewarm. Yes, he had a lot of good qualities, but she just was not feeling it. 

As the night wore on and the drinks and shots flowed, we took to dancing in the living room, and some of the moves got pretty racy, so we started forming circles around whomever was dancing the dirtiest to egg them on with our cheers and claps. We tried to push Chris to grind with Eddie, but she would casually avoid it, staying on the far end of the living room, dancing almost by herself.

I went to the bathroom and when I came back, there was a circle around Eddie and my wife, who were grinding. She kept bouncing and rubbing her ass against his crotch, one hand in the ground, the other in the air, making a circular motion. You could see that Eddie was visibly embarrassed and my wife was loving teasing him. As the circle moved to cheer for another couple, they separated and I noticed Eddie had a big bulge in his pants, that he quickly tried to hide by going to get a drink.

That night, I fucked my wife doggy style. As I was pouncing on her, I called her a little whore for dancing like that with Eddie, which made her moan even louder, so I asked her if she had felt that hard cock against her ass and she said yes, that it had made her so wet and horny. I, of course, was reaping the benefits of their dirty dancing.

I brought him up while fucking a couple of times after that, until I could tell that the memory of his cock aroused her. This made me confident enough to suggest that we invited him for a threesome some time. It would be our first planned threesome. She was open to the idea, but wanted to make sure Chris rejected him completely to avoid any problems with her. At this point Eddie had become part of the gang, and we even added him to a group chat for a concert we were going to attend.

I decided to talk to Chris directly, since we were good friends. I told her my plans and asked what she thought. She did not have a problem with it since she had decided not to take things further. She did feel awkward that he was now part of the group after she turned him down. She advised that we set up the encounter as an “spontaneous” thing, because he would probably be intimidated if we asked him straight up to join me in fucking my wife.

Gracious as she was, she offered to set it up by bringing him over casually for drinks and then either leaving or pretending to go to bed so it would be just the three of us. She made it clear that she would not participate, as she did not want to give him hope that they would get together romantically.

The night of the event, my wife wore tight black shorts and a low-cut with blouse, which gave a spectacular view of her 34D tits. We established some ground rules and set up gestures and passwords to signal each other to keep going or call things off.

Chris and Eddie arrived a little after nine, and it took us a while to get the ball rolling. Eventually, after enough drinking games, we started playing Truth or Dare, but Chris was doing a terrible job as a wingman. We thought that perhaps she had second thoughts about letting Eddie go.

Around midnight, Eddie said he was ready to leave, but then Chris nailed her role. She told him that he had drunk one too many, and that there was no way she was going to let him drive, but she could not drive either so they might as well just stay the night if it was OK with us. We agreed, of course, and I poured a round of shots. Chris downed hers and then said she was going to lie down for a while in the guest bedroom and asked us to provide Eddie with some blankets so he could sleep on the couch and then headed upstairs.

Eddie was visibly saddened at being shunned, so we poured him another round and tried to cheer him up. My wife went for it aggressively, sitting on his lap and doing the shot with him. He was visibly uncomfortable, so she got up and teased him about blushing.

The night went on with my wife flirting and saying everything but “fuck me.” I even told her in front of him to take her bra off, which she did right there and then, and then made a comment about her tits, to which Eddie only nodded. Then I pretended to pass out drunk, after which Eddy said he was going to bed. My wife carried my pretend-drunk ass upstairs, after which we fucked loudly, so he could hear us. Chris thought that the threesome was happening because of my wife’s loud moans.

We tried to have Eddie over a couple of times after that, but we could not make it happen.

Fast forward to my wife discovering my cheating and kicking me out of the house, and we went to a mediation session with our attorneys last week. After the meeting, she asked to talk to me for a minute and told me there was something she wanted me to hear from her, since we live in a mid-size town: She is dating Eddie. And he does have a big dick. Chris missed out. I guess that Eddie was just biding his time to fuck her without sharing.